Belle Bella Reged: 09/27/02 Posts: 117278 i'm still shocked at who kim took to the end and won LOL :) NT 05/21/12 08:06 AM Edit Reply Quote I miss you Crazyq Mark Thread Read Hide Thread Print Report Remind Me Link

Entire thread Subject Posted by Posted on I SO want to be proud it was a all woman finish, but I feel like they got to the end by default. Had Colton stayed it all changes. The men were sheep LuckyLizzie74 05/17/12 02:28 PM There's no telling what would have happened. Colton showed no strategy and only played to get rid of who he disliked NT BB8On 05/22/12 08:34 PM ITA. He is as over rated as Russell is self-delusional about his ability to win the game. NT FrouFrou 05/24/12 10:10 AM I'll admit he was good at getting people to go along with what he wanted, but I'm not convinced he would have recognized Kim as a threat NT BB8On 05/29/12 09:05 PM Kim still deserves full credit. She never laid back & let the game happen. NT PVRlover 05/19/12 05:50 PM She did well, and was clearly the best of the women. But it would have been MUCH more interesting seeing how she would have fared JAF 05/20/12 10:39 AM I don't believe the Idol Troy found would have been in play if Colton hadn't left with his NT BB8On 05/22/12 08:34 PM I found it interesting that every single on of the last six women would trust Kim with their lives. NT dizzy 05/21/12 07:34 AM Yep. Although it should be noted that the 3 of them that she fooled were Kat, Alicia, and Christina. Not exactly the sharpest tools in the shed. NT JAF 05/21/12 08:06 AM i'm still shocked at who kim took to the end and won LOL :) NT Belle 05/21/12 08:06 AM Initially I though it would make more sense to take 2 of the dummies instead of somewhat stronger players in Sabrina and Chelsea. But I think it JAF 05/21/12 08:16 AM lol well as you noted it didn't make a difference in kim's shoes Belle 05/21/12 08:28 AM It's interesting that she got ZERO votes while Sabrina managed 2. I would have voted for Kim in part because she played well JAF 05/21/12 08:41 AM i actually saw chelsea as more of a competor i don't know Belle 05/21/12 08:43 AM I think someone posted something saying Leif voted for Sabrina because "she's a minority like me" (::eyeroll::). Not sure about Troy. I'd guess JAF 05/21/12 09:57 AM I thought Chelsea had a better shot too. She was my favorite player by far. I think the edit had a lot to do with it. I was surprised at tribal tiredoflurking 05/21/12 08:50 AM good point i forgot all about that at TC NT Belle 05/21/12 09:31 AM The fact she wasnt tested actually is part due to her skill. She was very good at maintaining control. I do think she is a well above average player tas 05/20/12 10:42 AM You are wrong. Didn't you hear Troyzan. He is one of the best players ever...roflmao NT PVRlover 05/20/12 10:55 AM I agree, and Colton wouldnt have made it to final 3 anyhow. NT liannalu 05/19/12 11:22 PM ITA. Completely different game if Colton doesn't leave due to injury. He'd already blindsided Monica the week before showing JAF 05/18/12 01:10 PM Giving up Bill one of their strongest men was where it all went wrong, that and letting Colton lead the troops. Colton was a mean and spiteful man. flightsy 05/18/12 12:56 PM IMO it was Colton who handed them the game when he forced the men to go to tribal to get rid of Bill. NT FrouFrou 05/18/12 06:51 AM That made it closer but the men still had the numbers after that. The real killer was Colton leaving to injury. That tied it up JAF 05/18/12 01:06 PM It doesn't mean they would have stuck together. Troy & Jay knew the misfits wanted them gone NT PVRlover 05/20/12 11:00 AM Hard to tell. Their failure was not recognizing that the girls would re-join (seemed obvious to me and how they didn't see that still puzzles me). JAF 05/20/12 11:43 AM Yep, the caught that break and the men also giving up tribe immunity. Either one or both would have greatly altered the game. NT CougarSpy 05/17/12 02:32 PM

UBB.threads™ 6.2.1