Over the past few days, I’ve seen some bizarre fights. I’ve seen fake fights that didn’t fool anybody and I’ve seen real fights that are so absurd they appear fake. These fights are always predicated on silly minutia, as if the instigators were just grasping at some flimsy pretense to yell at someone.
I’m particularly fascinated by the notion of a fake fight. What is the purpose of a fake fight anyway, and has that purpose ever been accomplished? I suppose the putative benefit of a fake fight is to distance yourself from a real ally, to downplay an alliance that otherwise would bring heat on you. But I can’t remember one time that this strategy has actually succeeded. Moreover, participating in a fight is going to bring new heat on you.
So are fake fights worth their risk?
And the Award Goes to…
Ever since McCrae and Amanda have roped Elissa into their alliance, Amanda has been wary of being too transparent. She tells Elissa that they have to be careful about how much time they spend together and forewarns her that she will be standoffish to her in public. But after exploring this option for a little while, Amanda inexplicably concluded that it wasn’t enough.
Let the fake fight commence!
Amanda talks to Elissa outside and when she walks away she bleats to the other houseguests about how annoying Elissa is. She yells at Elissa from across the yard to keep talking her bullshit, taunting her that no matter how hard she finagles, she can’t save herself.
This fight was completely unnecessary. She was awkwardly yelling at Elissa for no reason and that is exactly how it looked. As is often the case with a fake fight, by attempting to cover-up one problem (and failing,) you create a new problem: Amanda comes out of this looking untrustworthy.
And the kicker is that Amanda was so proud of her performance, she can’t help but boast to the rest of her alliance about her Meryl Streep caliber performance. Great job, Amanda!
“This Indian needs a new teepee and I’m about to cut some buffalo up!”
Bring out the booze and bring on the confrontation! Jeremy purloins a bottle of wine for himself and his friends, and after Aaryn complains that other people are “mean-mugging” her and making snarky comments, Jeremy is primed for the attack. “Should I go say something?” he asks. “Probably, yeah,” replies Aaryn.
Jeremy then marches into the kitchen, berating everyone for being indignant over him stealing the wine. He says that if anyone has an issue with it, they should talk to him instead of whispering and implicating his friends.
In textbook Jeremy fashion, he appears to be making a concerted effort to be non-confrontational as he creates confrontations. To his credit, he is rather calm, albeit irrational, throughout most of this fight. But then he will slip up and make some incendiary comment like, “And I promise you this just adds more fire, so you might want to tell them to apologize, kiss my toe, and suck my dick, or something.”
“I came into this bitch athletic, sexy, and ready to play,” Jeremy reminds us. Did I not tell you this guy was going to be entertaining?
Aaryn: “I tried to put a pizza in and McCrae snapped at me.”
Jeremy: “What did he say?”
Aaryn: “’Put in on the rack. Just put it directly on the rack.’ And I was like, ‘Well, the last time I tried to put it on the rack, someone told me to just put it on something.’ So I was putting it on a pan. He goes, ‘You don’t need to.’ Whoa! I thought he didn’t want a target on his back.”
Jeremy: “That’s all he said?”
What is going on with this girl? I can’t believe that anyone is actually this antagonistic. But she is confiding to her alliance; why would she lie about this? I can only assume that Aaryn is assuming this bitchy demeanor to take on some kind of villain status, ensuring her ample TV time. After Jeremy’s aforementioned blowup, Aaryn seizes the opportunity to reprise her ridiculous fight with Candice concerning her hat that Candice allegedly sat on. Turns out, Spencer just made up this story about Candice, but that hardly matters.
As always, Candice apologizes for something she never did and Aaryn finds something else objectionable with the apology. The first time, Aaryn bitched her out for pronouncing “ask” as “axe.” Now, she is bemoaning Candice’s “condescending remark” about her hat being worth 10 dollars.
Hypothetical situation: Candice wins the POV. She walks up to Aaryn and inexplicably says, “Hey Aaryn, I know we’ve had some misunderstandings, but I’ve decided to give you the power of veto in the ceremony today.”
Aaryn: “Fuck you, Candice! You think that I need your help? Do you think you can buy my friendship, like I’m some kind of prostitute or something! Oh my god, did you just call me a whore!? You’re such a bitch! And why do you have to call it the POV? Do you think you're cool or something? Just say power of veto for Christ’s sake! God, you’re a loser! And change that shirt before you think about talking to me again! It’s like you’re trying to piss me off!”
Fight Club Reprised
Having a fight in the Big Brother house is a move that reeks of desperation. The primary issue is that most people get paranoid and their paranoia becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy ensuring their eviction. However—as they say—desperate times call for desperate measures: When you are in danger it may be to your benefit to wreck some havoc among alliances.
But these people are beyond paranoid. They are fighting for sport. There is nothing to be gained here, only lost.
|Big Brother 18 House of Mirrors: Mix Up|
The problem with Vets vs. Newbies
|Twas the Night Before BB...|
And all through the house!
|Big Brother 18 House of Mirrors: Scouting Report|
Your guide to the Big Brother 18 cast
|A Different Kind of American Idol|
Ever thought you could act? Here's your shot, with a real exercise from the AADA.
|BB Canada Psych: What Are They Really Saying?|
Joker's psychoanalyzes the deep meaning behind what Kelsey, the Cowboy and others say. BB conversations are rife with various layers.
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: Mic Check, One Two|
The Boy Becomes a Man, End of the Season Awards, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: Enter the Dumb|
Reflecting on the Big Brother 17 Takeovers, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: As Expected|
The best social game of the season, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: Sneaky Steve!|
The evolution of Boy, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: And the Verdict Is . . .|
Begging Big Brother production for more alcohol, begging the jury to give Vanessa a chance, and out of context quotes.
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: Welcome to the Imaginarium|
How to avoid being your alliance's pawn, and the pleasures of an Austin HoH
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: Stop, Collaborate, and Listen|
The intricacies of being an adaptable Big Brother player, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: Welcome to Big Brother|
The game starts anew as Battle of the Block is terminated, and I delve into some bizarre Austin fan-fiction. Itís going to get weird.
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: The Superfan Shootout|
Checking in with our resident Big Brother superfans, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: Systematic Chaos|
Battle of the Block malaise, and my curious frustration with Vanessa's week as HOH
|BB17 From Inside the Furball Chapter 5|
Under The Sink
|Ette-take - the Thigh's the Limit & Head of What?|
Meg just hit my "favorite HG" meter from the quote inside.
|Big Brother 17 House of Mirrors: Pretzel Logic|
Coming down from the twisted madness of week one, and how to select the perfect pawn
|Ette-Take 2: When the Feeds Go Off...|
Philosophers climb out of hiding, questions of deep mystery are posed and discussed...
|BB17 From Inside the Furball Chapter 4|
Big Brother Furball Award
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: The Drinks are on Andy|
My final thoughts on Big Brother 15, the reunion, and Andy
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: The Amanda Show|
Amanda's arrival at the jury house, end of the season awards, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: The Lying Game|
Andy's legacy, conspiracy theories, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: John Nash in the House!|
Amanda doesn't listen to music, Elissa smiles, and Andy and Elissa fight over the meaning of "threaten"
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: Fighting the World|
Jessie pisses everybody off, Amanda gets her Axl Rose on, and out of context quotes
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: The Path of Least Resistance|
Double eviction madness, Amanda's conversational skills, and the person I want to come back in the house
|Big Brother 15 - Live Audience Experience|
Sharing my Big Brother studio audience experience, from start to finish!
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: Cause Without a Rebel|
Candice inadvertently invokes a skit from Chappelle's Show, and I go on another diatribe about the MVP twist
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: America's Sweetheart|
Passages from The Fountainhead, the glaring contradictions of Elissa, and one of my favorite houseguests I never get to write about
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: Aliens Exist|
GinaMarie stars in The Fugitive, and is Aaryn a racist?
|Big Brother House of Mirrors: You and Your Phonies|
McCrae pretends to be MVP, Howard unsuccessfully throws a competition, and Aaryn tries to apologize
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: Say Cheese!|
My take on the MVP twist, and Helen's penchant for Nirvana
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: Too Much Too Soon|
A look at the insanely fast pace of the game so far, and the art of the Jeremy apology
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: For Your Love|
An evaluation of the major Big Brother 15 showmances
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: Fight Club|
Amanda displays her acting chops, Jeremy steals some wine, and Aaryn cooks some pizza
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: Pretty in Pink|
Aaryn expresses her disappointment with David, Jeremy and Elissa discuss Gisele Bundchen, and David wears a dress
|Big Brother 15 House of Mirrors: Scouting Report|
Your guide to the Big Brother 15 cast